I love Christmas movies and I’ve been rating them as I watch on my Facebook profile. I’ve had some request to consolidate so people can see how the movies ranked. I’ve also added an extra notation if there’s LGBTQ+ content in the movie. So, here’s everything I’ve watched so far since holiday movie season began (for me it started on October 25). I’ll keep watching through New Year’s weekend.

I use a five tree (🎄) rating system and then add bonus stars (⭐️) if a movie went above and beyond. At the bottom, you’ll find the number of movies I didn’t finish.

This list is updated a final time on January 2. Christmas 2020 was an epic season for movies!

All the Trees and All the Stars rating
(aka, all the trees and all the stars)
The Christmas Setup (Lifetime) LGBTQ romance

Five Trees plus Three Bonus Stars rating
A Sugar & Spice Holiday (Lifetime)
Dashing in December (Paramount Network) LGBTQ romance
Jingle Jangle: A Christmas Journey (Netflix)
Christmas She Wrote (Hallmark Channel) Minor LGBTQ characters
Christmas Ever After (Lifetime)
The Christmas House (Hallmark Channel) Major LGBTQ subplot

Five Trees plus Two Bonus Stars rating
Let’s Meet Again on Christmas Eve (Lifetime)
The Christmas Aunt (Lifetime)
Christmas in Evergreen: Bells are Ringing (Hallmark Channel) Minor LGBTQ characters
Christmas by Starlight (Hallmark Channel) Minor LGBTQ characters
The Christmas Doctor (Hallmark Movies & Mysteries)
A Timeless Christmas (Hallmark Channel)
Holly & Ivy (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)

Five Trees plus One Bonus Stars rating
Dear Christmas (Lifetime)
People Presents: Once Upon a Time on Main Street (Lifetime)
The Christmas Edition (Lifetime)
A Christmas Carousel (Hallmark Channel)
Christmas Comes Twice (Hallmark Channel)
A Glenbrooke Christmas (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
Love, Lights, Hanukkah (Hallmark Channel) (in this case 🕎🕎🕎🕎🕎)
Christmas Waltz (Hallmark Channel)
The Angel Tree (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
This Christmas Bow (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
One Royal Holiday (Hallmark Channel)
Chateau Christmas (Hallmark Channel)

5 trees rating
Cross Country Christmas (Hallmark Channel)
Unlocking Christmas (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
Time for Us to Come Home for Christmas (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
Good Morning Christmas (Hallmark Channel)
Five Star Christmas (Hallmark Channel)
Heart of the Holidays (Hallmark Channel)
Christmas in Vienna (Hallmark Channel)
The Christmas Ring (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
Cranberry Christmas (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
Christmas Tree Lane (Hallmark Channel)
Jingle Bell Bride (Hallmark Channel)
Christmas on Ice (Lifetime)

Four trees rating
Project Christmas Wish (Hallmark Movies & Mysteries)
Lonestar Christmas (Lifetime)
Inn Love by Christmas (Lifetime)
Too Close for Christmas (Lifetime)
The Princess Switch: Switched Again (Netflix)
A Christmas Tree Grows in Colorado (Hallmark Channel) Minor LGBTQ characters
Christmas on the Vine (Lifetime)
Meet Me at Christmas (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)
Christmas with the Darlings (Hallmark Channel)
On the 12th Date of Christmas (Hallmark Channel) Minor LGBTQ characters
A Crafty Christmas Romance (Lifetime)
Delivery by Christmas (Hallmark Movies and Mysteries)

Three trees rating
Feliz NaviDAD (Lifetime)
Santa Squad (Lifetime)
If I Only Had Christmas (Hallmark Movies & Mysteries)
USS Christmas (Hallmark Movies & Mysteries)
Happiest Season (Hulu) Major LGBTQ Story
Never Kiss a Man in a Christmas Sweater (Hallmark Channel)
Candy Cane Christmas (Lifetime)

Did not finish: 7
No titles are given here. Christmas movies are very subjective and just because I didn’t like one doesn’t mean you won’t so I’m not going to allow my negative opinions to sway what you watch.